Drag

BCAAs: do athletes need them?

Carlos Soler

No supplement can replace a good diet, but we do enjoy discussing sports supplements here. What about BCAAs? Why are these compounds so popular among athletes?

More importantly, should you supplement them, or can you meet your needs through food?

Our team member Carlos Soler, a sports nutritionist, explains.

 

What are BCAAs and what do they do?

First, let’s define BCAAs.

BCAA stands for branched-chain amino acids.

They comprise valine, leucine and isoleucine, named for their branched chemical structure.

Together they account for nearly a third of skeletal muscle amino acids in the human body and play an important role in protein synthesis, as well as serving as precursors to glutamine and alanine.

They can also be metabolised in the muscles to provide energy during exercise.

 

Runner after taking BCAAs

 

Are BCAAs essential amino acids?

Yes. These three compounds are among the nine essential amino acids, also known as EAAs, that the body cannot make in sufficient amounts and must obtain through food.

Rich sources include meat and meat products, fish, shellfish, milk, dairy products and eggs, as well as egg products. Our post on 7 keto dinners includes recipes featuring these foods.

 

Foods rich in BCAAs

 

Potential BCAA benefits for athletes

The effectiveness of these supplements has not been demonstrated 100%, although studies have associated branched-chain amino acids with the following potential benefits.

 

Stimulation of protein synthesis

Leucine may stimulate protein synthesis, but the other amino acids are also needed for the process to function normally. Eating protein of high biological value can achieve this too.

 

Muscle tissue recovery after exercise

BCAA supplementation may reduce soreness in muscles after intense eccentric exercise and support recovery. However, with a diet supplying more than 1.2 g/kg/day of protein, the additional effects may be negligible.

 

Reduced perception of fatigue

There is very little scientific evidence that BCAA supplementation in aerobic sports reduces fatigue by limiting tryptophan entry into the central nervous system.

Combining BCAAs with arginine and citrulline may alter the tryptophan/BCAA ratio and increase ammonia excretion, potentially reducing perceived fatigue.

This hypothesis needs further research.

 

Cyclists using BCAA supplements

 

Potential risks of BCAAs

Can supplementing these amino acids cause problems?

Animal toxicity studies suggest that BCAA supplementation is generally safe, although this does not establish suitability for every individual.

People with conditions associated with obesity, such as insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular diseases, have shown chronically elevated blood BCAA levels. Increasing intake in these circumstances could be redundant and ineffective.

 

When should you take BCAAs?

As discussed above, supplementation is unnecessary when you follow a balanced, protein-rich diet.

If supplementation is appropriate, intake may be divided throughout the day, including during training or after exercise in liquid form.

 

Do I need BCAAs if I exercise?

The short answer is no. A well-planned omnivorous or vegetarian diet, including eggs and dairy, can provide an appropriate amount of protein to cover your needs.

A sports nutritionist can advise whether supplementation suits your particular needs.

 

Runner using a BCAA supplement

 

How are BCAAs taken?

BCAA supplements come in several forms, most commonly capsules or powder.

 

What doses are discussed?

Some protocols mention 1,500–6,000 mg/day of leucine and 800–3,000 mg/day of isoleucine and valine.

A commonly discussed amount is 20 grams of BCAAs, combining leucine, isoleucine and valine in a stated ratio, A:B:C. Many supplements use a 2:1:1 ratio in an effort to improve effectiveness.

 

Person taking BCAA supplements

 

BCAAs and glutamine: why combine them?

Glutamine is often included with BCAAs. Why?

A key leucine transporter in muscle fibres is LAT1. Entry of leucine into muscle cells is coupled to the exit of glutamine.

Insufficient glutamine could therefore limit leucine entry and its role in protein synthesis.

Nevertheless, the scientific studies discussed here do not justify combining these supplements; much remains to be researched.

 

Putting it together

You now know what BCAAs are, what they do in the body and how they might relate to your sporting goals.

BCAA supplements are discussed here as Group B supplements.

This means there is some evidence of a beneficial effect, but findings are not fully consistent. Further research is needed to clarify how they may help.

Group B supplements may be used within individualised protocols tailored to an athlete’s needs.

A sports nutritionist can assess your case and decide whether BCAA supplementation is appropriate, or whether your daily requirements can be met through your nutrition plan.

Unsure what to eat to give your body what it needs? Our team can handle your nutrition planning in detail, leaving you to focus on giving your best in training.

Explore our subscription options and take another step towards improving your sporting performance.

When shall we start?

Te puede interesar

Cómo plantear un menú sin gluten para deportistas

How to Design a Gluten-Free Meal Plan for Athletes

There is a myth that without traditional carbohydrate sources, such as wheat pasta or bread, performance will plummet. In reality, however, it is perfectly possible to compete at the highest level without consuming a single gram of gluten.
intervals e INDYA

INDYA integrates with Intervals.icu: training and nutrition connected

The integration allows INDYA to incorporate information from workouts recorded in Intervals.icu, such as training time, estimated energy expenditure and the effort level of each session. This data can then be used alongside the athlete’s training history to personalize their nutritional plan.
Pliegues cutáneos: medición e interpretación

Skinfolds: Measuring and Interpreting Body Fat

Skinfold measurement is one of the most widely used tools in anthropometry for assessing body composition and monitoring a patient's or athlete's progress.