Drag

40 common nutrition myths

Marta Aguilar

We encounter nutrition myths every day.

People naturally want control over their surroundings. “It depends” and different answers to the same question can feel uncomfortable. We want certainty: good or bad, yes or no, true or false, works or doesn’t.

Add our tendency to simplify decisions—or sell easy answers—and food becomes fertile ground for myths, half-truths, exaggerations, simplistic headlines, sensationalism, biased interpretations and confusion. Here are some familiar examples:

1. Fruit raises blood sugar

Whole fruit contains sugars, but that is not a reason to avoid it. Its food matrix, fibre and water influence how quickly we eat it, fullness and glucose responses compared with many added-sugar products or juices. Fruit can still raise blood glucose; choose portions suited to your needs rather than assuming unlimited quantities are right for everyone. Spread intake through the day and enjoy edible, washed skins where appropriate.

2. If you exercise, you need protein bars

There are many products, and usefulness depends on your circumstances. A bar can be convenient away from home when protein-rich food is unavailable, but is not essential every day. Check the ingredients and nutrition label: a protein claim does not mean protein is the largest ingredient or that the product suits your goals.

3. Spinach for iron, oranges for vitamin C, milk for calcium, mussels for phosphorus and bananas for potassium

If only nutrition were so simple. Many foods have become the symbol of a nutrient despite plenty of other sources. Spinach contains non-haem iron, generally less readily absorbed than haem iron from animal foods. Vitamin C helps non-haem iron absorption. Beans and lentils can also provide iron; fish, eggs, mature cheese, soya, nuts, yoghurt, avocado, kiwi, red peppers, broccoli and Brussels sprouts offer various minerals and vitamins. Rankings depend on portions and preparation, so do not attach each nutrient to a single food. Time to move beyond the 80s: Popeye was a cartoon, after all.

4. You have to train fasted

Fasted training may be used for a specific session goal under appropriate guidance, but it is not compulsory. An overnight fast does not automatically empty muscle glycogen, and greater fat oxidation during one session does not guarantee greater fat loss. Discuss suitability with your coach and nutritionist. Read more in our post on intermittent fasting.

lactose-free means healthier - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

5. Lactose-free is healthier

No. Lactose-free is not a nutritional-quality label. If you tolerate lactose, you need not avoid it; choosing a lactose-free product is also fine. Look at the overall ingredients and nutrition.

Lactase breaks down lactose. Low lactase activity can leave lactose poorly digested and cause symptoms. Many lactose-free dairy products use added lactase to split the sugar, though production methods vary. If you tolerate ordinary dairy, lactose itself is not a reason to exclude it.

6. “Veggie” means healthier

Building meals around vegetables, pulses and fruit is a useful start, but a vegetarian diet can also be dominated by biscuits, refined grains, soft drinks, fried foods and highly processed products. Vegetarian does not automatically mean healthy or low-calorie. Nuts, avocado, oils and coconut milk can be energy-dense; vegetarian foods such as eggs, cheese, butter and cream are animal-derived and have different fat profiles. Portions and the overall diet matter.

7. You must sweat to burn fat

Sweating regulates temperature; it does not measure fat loss. Hard indoor cycling often relies heavily on carbohydrate and can use substantial glycogen, while sweating removes fluid. Refuelling restores glycogen, but that does not mean the session had no effect on longer-term energy balance. Both lower- and higher-intensity activity can contribute to fitness and appropriate weight management. Sweating more is not the goal =)

8. To lose weight, skip dinner or eat very little

Not necessarily. If fat loss is appropriate, consider overall energy intake, not dinner alone. After late training, a substantial dinner may support recovery; before an early session, it can help prepare fuel stores.

9. To lose weight, avoid carbohydrates at dinner

Although sleep usually follows dinner, carbohydrates can replenish glycogen and support normal glucose availability. Overall energy balance and training needs matter more than an automatic evening ban.

organic means healthier - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

10. Organic or “bio” means healthier

Organic labels describe production standards, not a guarantee of nutritional superiority. They have specific requirements, but do not automatically mean a product is more sustainable or healthier in every respect. Read ingredients and include fruit and vegetables, with local seasonal choices where practical. A “super” label is no guarantee either: explore your local market.

11. Weight loss means salads, boiled foods, lettuce and grilled chicken

We may associate these dishes with fewer calories, but ingredients and portions determine energy content. A salad with avocado, chicken, nuts, feta and Caesar dressing may be energy-dense, as can a traditional stew with bacon, black pudding and plenty of oil.

12. Lemon water is a detox

There is no good evidence that morning lemon water burns fat or “cleanses” or “detoxifies” the body. If you enjoy it as a refreshing drink, that is a different reason to have it.

13. Take vitamins just in case

Both deficiency and excessive intake can harm health. Assess your diet and circumstances with a qualified professional, using targeted blood tests where appropriate. Routine testing of every vitamin is not necessary for everyone; supplementation should address an identified need.

14. Intermittent fasting is the key to fat loss

For fat loss, an appropriate sustained calorie deficit matters. A shorter eating window helps some people manage intake, but fasting does not reliably outperform a comparable energy deficit. Whether it suits you depends on your circumstances.

homemade means more nutritious - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

15. Homemade means more nutritious

Homemade is not automatically healthy. Cakes and biscuits can still contain plenty of refined flour, sugar and fat. On the other hand, a homemade pizza with suitable ingredients and portions, like this one or this one, can be a nutritious meal.

16. Wholegrain or high-fibre foods make you lose weight

Whole grains contain fibre, but not every high-fibre product is wholegrain. Fibre can support fullness and make intake easier to manage; it does not cause weight loss regardless of energy balance. Read Fibre and sports performance.

17. Better performance requires keto and no carbohydrates

A ketogenic diet is not appropriate for everyone and can have disadvantages for some exercise demands, as discussed in this post. It changes fuel use, but does not automatically improve performance or cause greater fat loss than other suitable diets. Find more in this other post.

18. Pasta makes you gain weight

No single food determines weight gain. If energy intake consistently exceeds expenditure, weight can rise even with nutritious food choices. Pasta portions and the whole diet matter.

19. No fruit at night

A common myth, but fruit does not become inherently unsuitable after a particular hour. If you tolerate it and the portion suits your needs, fruit can be a useful evening choice.

extra virgin olive oil is healthy in any amount - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

20. Extra virgin olive oil is healthy in any amount

Extra virgin describes oil quality, not fewer calories. Oil is almost entirely fat, providing more than twice the energy per gram of carbohydrate or protein. Manage cooking and dressing quantities with a spoon or oil spray rather than an uncontrolled pour lasting 5 seconds. The oil remains nutritious; excess energy may simply not fit your goal.

21. Sugar kills

Sugar sources differ in food matrix, nutrients and practical use. Whole fruit is not equivalent to a sports gel. During demanding exercise, a suitable gel’s readily available carbohydrate can support performance; it does not need to be labelled universally good or bad.

22. Sweat removes toxins

Sweating primarily regulates temperature. It also removes water and electrolytes, so replace losses appropriately. It is not an effective “detox” strategy, and more sweating is not inherently better.

23. Light products have few calories

Under the relevant legislation, a “light” claim follows reduction conditions, generally at least 30% less energy or the named nutrient than a comparable product, with specific exceptions and an explanation of the reduction. It does not always mean fewer calories, low fat or superior nutrition. Read the product and portion information rather than relying on the claim alone.

24. Gluten-free is better

Gluten-containing foods can provide fibre, iron, folate and other nutrients. Gluten contributes texture, and substitutes may need additional ingredients. Coeliac disease, wheat allergy and other diagnosed conditions require appropriate guidance. Without a relevant condition, routine gluten restriction has no established universal benefit; there is no general need to limit it merely because it is gluten.

no more than 3–5 eggs a week - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

25. No more than 3–5 eggs a week

A fixed weekly rule does not fit everyone. The original article proposed 1–3 eggs daily, or 7–21 weekly, with absolute claims of cardiovascular protection. Those amounts should not be treated as a universal recommendation. Eggs supply high-quality protein, vitamins and minerals, but dietary cholesterol can affect blood cholesterol and suitability depends on the overall diet and health context.

26. Protein is only for muscles

Protein has many roles beyond muscle. Enzymes, transport proteins and body structures all depend on amino acids. Some amino acids can also be used for energy, although protein is not usually the main exercise fuel.

27. Supplements are unhealthy

Some supplements have good evidence for specific uses. Whether one is appropriate depends on the person, need, dose, timing, safety and product quality. Read the A, B, C and D of supplementation.

28. Athletes cannot be vegan

Many myths surround vegan and vegetarian diets. A well-planned, individualised diet can meet athletes’ needs, whether omnivorous, vegetarian or vegan. Certain nutrients need particular attention, especially reliable vitamin B12 provision. Our “Perform without Meat” workshop explains more ; )

29. Fish is toxic because of mercury

Not every fish species has high mercury levels, and guidance differs for vulnerable groups. Choose species and portions accordingly. Read Fish and mercury for more information.

wine is heart-healthy and beer aids recovery - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

30. Wine is heart-healthy and beer is a good recovery drink

Alcohol is toxic and carcinogenic. Polyphenol content does not make alcoholic drinks a health recommendation. Get these compounds from foods such as pulses, vegetables and red or purple fruit instead.

Beer supplies fluid and some nutrients, but alcohol can impair recovery and fluid balance, and ordinary beer does not provide a suitable electrolyte replacement strategy. Do not rely on it as a recovery drink.

31. Orange juice is “bad sugar”

Compared with whole fruit, juice usually has less fibre and fullness: 1. A glass may contain the juice from several oranges, which is easier to consume quickly than whole fruit. 2. The reduced fibre and altered matrix change the context of sugar intake. A food rich in readily available carbohydrate can give a different glucose response from a meal also containing fibre, fat and protein. Orange juice alone differs from juice with wholemeal toast and scrambled eggs. Glycaemic load considers glycaemic index and available carbohydrate per portion; it is not simply the sum of a meal’s glycaemic indices.

32. Butter is bad

Butter is rich in saturated fat. Margarine varies by formulation: modern soft margarines often contain unsaturated fats and little industrial trans fat. Partial hydrogenation can create trans fats, but not all margarines require it or have the same composition. Compare labels and the overall dietary pattern.

33. Red meat causes cancer

Cancer risk cannot be reduced to one isolated meal. However, processed meat is classified as carcinogenic and red meat as probably carcinogenic, based on the available evidence. Amount, frequency and cooking practices matter; an occasional serving should not be described as guaranteeing zero risk.

34. Avoid all processed foods

Distinguish processed from ultra-processed foods. Many foods undergo useful processing for safety and shelf life. Extra virgin olive oil, cheese and yoghurt are processed foods that can fit a nutritious diet, depending on the product and portion.

fat loss requires a fat-free diet - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

35. Fat loss requires a fat-free diet

Eating fat does not automatically increase body fat. An appropriate sustainable deficit matters. After ensuring sufficient protein, distribute the remaining energy between suitable carbohydrate and fat sources according to needs, training and preferences.

36. More protein means more muscle

Adequate protein, training and rest support muscle gain, but benefits do not keep increasing indefinitely with intake. The original article gives 1.8–2.2 g/kg as an illustrative daily range, to be adapted to each athlete’s circumstances.

37. No biscuits or cake

Context, ingredients and portions matter. Wholemeal flour, fruit and nuts can contribute nutrients, but a homemade cake is not automatically low in sugar or calories. Packaged products vary too: assess their labels and place in the overall diet.

38. You must eat 5 meals a day

A classic myth. You do not have to eat 5 times daily. The best meal pattern depends on your lifestyle, appetite and training; 5 meals suit some people but not others. Meet overall nutritional needs in a manageable way.

39. Everyone must drink 2 L of water daily

General figures of 2–2.5 L a day are often mentioned, but needs vary with sex, body size, lifestyle, exercise, food intake, altitude, temperature and humidity. Personalise fluid intake and avoid forced overdrinking.

40. Pizza, burgers and sandwiches are unhealthy

We often associate these meals with fast food, but ingredients and portions vary enormously. A carefully prepared homemade version can have a very different nutritional profile. Judge the meal itself, rather than its name alone.

pizza, burgers and sandwiches are unhealthy - 40 nutrition myths - INDYA

Conclusion: as these myths show, nutrition headlines can mix science with fiction. No food label, recipe name or diet category alone tells the whole story about health or weight. Human nutrition is more complex.

As we were beginning to emerge from lockdown when this original post was written, we hoped to break free of these 40 myths too.

If that inspires you to improve sports performance with planned nutrition, explore our online sports nutritionist services. We look forward to meeting you.

Te puede interesar

Cómo plantear un menú sin gluten para deportistas

How to Design a Gluten-Free Meal Plan for Athletes

There is a myth that without traditional carbohydrate sources, such as wheat pasta or bread, performance will plummet. In reality, however, it is perfectly possible to compete at the highest level without consuming a single gram of gluten.
intervals e INDYA

INDYA integrates with Intervals.icu: training and nutrition connected

The integration allows INDYA to incorporate information from workouts recorded in Intervals.icu, such as training time, estimated energy expenditure and the effort level of each session. This data can then be used alongside the athlete’s training history to personalize their nutritional plan.
Pliegues cutáneos: medición e interpretación

Skinfolds: Measuring and Interpreting Body Fat

Skinfold measurement is one of the most widely used tools in anthropometry for assessing body composition and monitoring a patient's or athlete's progress.